Photo (c) Camille Martin
(This essay was initially published on the Poetries & Communities Project curated by MARGENTO at UOttawa
here)
Community:
a social unit with common values OR a group of interacting living organisms sharing a populated environment. (definitions paraphrased/cribbed from Wikipedia).
I have several communities: my apartment building; Chinatown, the
neighbourhood in which I live; the city of Ottawa; its literary
community; Canada; North America; the world; and within all those
places, I am also in that literary community.
I imagine a series of globes nesting inside one another like Russian
dolls. For me community is symbiotic: its members contribute to one
another’s well-being and being in the community contributes to the
well-being of its members. This is starting to sound like a palindrome
or a Möbius strip.
For the purposes of this note, let’s consider the idea of community
as the general public within my city. I am a member of the public, just
as all poets are.
In this note, I don’t choose to address in detail a very important
aspect of community because I’ve dealt with it elsewhere: that of people
helping one another in times of crisis and how such actions bring a
community closer together. In 2009 I became very ill. While I was in
hospital and near death, members of Ottawa’s close-knit and caring
literary community came to my and my husband’s assistance. For more on
that experience, please refer to
this post entitled “Community” in the “On Writing” series curated by rob mclennan.
How would you define the relationship between (your) poetry and
(or poetry in general; as it does or should converge with)
communities/the community?
I listen and I look. Wherever I go I am always in receiver mode. My
poetry comes from the intersection between what I see and hear around
me, interactions with others and my imagination, experiences, memory and
knowledge of other literary works, music, art and other cultural works.
I filter all this through my brain and somehow neurons fire up.
Fortunately I don’t set the page on fire.
I read at readings which the general public can attend. It’s true
that not everyone is interested in poetry or has a reason to go to a
reading, just as not all of us are interested in hockey. A former lover
of mine once said, “if everyone loved oatmeal, there would be a
worldwide shortage of oatmeal.”
Audiences who have come to my readings or other readings I have
attended are there because they are interested in my work or my fellow
writers’ work; because they are friends or family, are also poets
reading at the open mic or are enthusiasts of whatever type of
literature is being featured. It is lovely when people come up to me
after a reading to let me know that they were affected in some way by
what I read. At one reading at Café Nostalgica at the University of
Ottawa several years ago, a young student told me that my reading had
inspired him to pick up a pen and write while I was reading. I thought
this was a high compliment. Engaging with audience members is an
essential part of my practice.
I run a site called Bywords.ca, which publishes poetry monthly by
current and former Ottawa residents, students and workers. The main idea
of the site is to foster and nurture community, to give back to the
general public at large and to promote Ottawa writers in general and to
publish poets. These writers and the visitors to the site are also part
of my community, as are the selectors and other members of the
Bywords.ca team.
One of the key features of the site is a calendar of literary and
spoken word events which take place in Canada’s National Capital Region.
Event organizers send me information about their readings, signings,
slams, festivals, workshops etc and I post them on the calendar and also
send out notices via social media (Twitter (@bywordsdotca) and
FaceBook).
My mission is to ensure that nobody who is interested in Ottawa’s
literary events misses an event because they don’t know about it. We
have been very fortunate to have been funded for the last eleven years
by the City of Ottawa so that we can pay contributing poets, musicians
and artists. The City also funds other cultural organizations and
individual artists to help ensure that the artistic community thrives
and is able to provide the public with an enriched and culturally
diverse experience. Without such a commitment it would be difficult for
such organizations to offer services to the general public.
We also hold at least one fundraising activity a year for local causes, including
Cornerstone Housing for Women, which provides emergency housing and support to downtown women and
the AIDS/HIV Walk for Life Ottawa,
which raises funds for several local organizations that provide care
and support to people with AIDS/HIV and their families. I believe that
it is one of the roles of any organization working within a community to
give back to its residents since we are all part of the community.
Poets can be homeless or afflicted with various health issues and
financial difficulties too. We are all connected. We need one another.
In addition to the above activities, I run
AngelHousePress,
which publishes ragged edges, raw talent and rebels. The publishing
activity takes the form of limited edition chapbooks, and two on-line
magazines:
Experiment-O.com and
NationalPoetryMonth.ca. We also host an essay series on
AngelHousePress.com.
These essays are written by working contemporary writers and artists
and serve to aid in the continuation of dialogue about creativity,
literature and art. I am interested in inspiring dialogue between
creative people, just as much as I am in inspiring responses from the
reading public. I think both types of response are equally valid and
interesting.
I consider AngelHousePress to be another avenue for fostering and
nurturing community. Creative work from all over the world is showcased
via AngelHouse and accessible to anyone who might be captivated by it.
The Internet to me has shrank the world and enlarged the world: the
former because now anyone in the world is able to connect with anyone
else of similar interest and proclivities; the latter because the World
Wide Web is a gargantuan digital repository much like a dump where one
can find both treasures and junk. This is why it is helpful to have
curators to find the treasure and alert people to it. I consider myself
to be a curator.
I also have
a literary blog
where I let people know about my work, but also tell them about
literaria I find interesting, whether it be poetry collections or
chapbooks or online magazines or podcasts or even going a wee bit
outside the range of literature and including music. I do this because I
am always looking for connection, collaboration opportunities and
intimacy with like-minded people… to create a community of kindreds.
How do collective energies find their voice in your verse and how
do you think your poems (should) reach communal interests/relevance?
I like Margaret Atwood’s answer to Peter Gzowski in a 1968 CBC
interview just after she’d won the Governor General’s Award when he
asked her what her poems were about. She said that poetry, like any art
form, is a form of expression, and that no one asked an artist what his
painting was about. So I don’t think about specific interests or
relevance, but we’re all human. My poems tend to have an emotional
resonance that, all being well, is something readers can empathize with
and relate to.
And faced with the onslaught of cases of social injustice, violence,
poverty, natural disaster and disease, the illnesses and deaths of those
I hold dear, I am as affected as anyone by tragedy and I find that
there’s an echo of this in my work. I always hope that what I write
resonates with someone, a fellow lonely person or a whimsical person,
someone who can identify with my work. I am a misfit in conventional
society, as many of us are. Writing and reading are ways in which I try
to find and connect with my fellow misfits. I should point out that many
of my long poems or poem series are written in the voice of a
historical or imaginary character. I think that such a form can have
universal resonance and create empathy in a reader.
Sometimes I will write a poem in support of a cause, such as “The
Enpipe Line: 70,000+ kilometres of poetry written in resistance to the
Enbridge Northern Gateway Pipelines proposal,” (Creekstone Press, March,
2012) or “Air Out/Air In: 21 Poets for the Guatemala Stove Project”
(Phafours, 2011).
At various rallies on Parliament Hill, I have encountered a number of
my fellow poets protesting or supporting a cause. I believe that poets
can be and are often engaged members of a community, as is this case,
here in Ottawa. Whether they choose to refer directly to this in their
poetry or whether such activism plays a more subtle role is up to them.
My priority is always to serve the poem and do whatever is necessary to
achieve what is called for within the work.
In this age of globalization and transnational poetries (Jahan
Ramazani’s term, but not only) what do you think is the ‘community’ the
poet addresses, if any, and what do you think are or may be the premises
for emerging virtual and/or trans-national readerships (the “coming
community” of theory again—G. Agamben—if you want)?
Here I’d like to give a specific example of a global community I
belong to: the visual poetry community. We find out about one another
through on-line and print magazines and blogs that publish our work,
through FaceBook groups, through sites like Tumblr, Pinterest and
Twitter where people share links and post work from various visual
poets. Through AngelHousePress I have published visual poets from
Hungary, Italy, Germany, France, England, Canada, the USA and probably
other places. Visual poetry lends itself very well to globalization
because it works outside of the context of languages in that you don’t
have to understand a particular language to appreciate the work as a
piece of art or a form of communication.
When discussing the community the poet addresses, I have to refer to
the main thesis of this note: that poets are part of the community. At
least that’s how I see myself. I’m writing for myself but also for other
misfits and unconventional kindreds. I’m writing for anyone who has
ever felt an emotion. This doesn’t change because poetry is able to be
read or heard on line throughout the world. In fact, it only makes me
more determined to publish online in order to share my work as widely as
possible and to connect with other like-minded readers and writers. The
question is mainly one of dissemination. I am grateful to translators
who make it possible for me to read the works of poets who are writing
in languages other than English.
Is there anything nowadays such as communities/schools of poets,
in any way relevant to the life of communities around the poets?
Academia continues to attract poets to its programs. I have a number
of poetry pals who have worked toward their MFAs in Creative Writing in
Canada of late. This is fairly new in Canada, but has been a big part
of poetry in the USA. I’m not sure if other countries have such
programs. The general public consists of students and family of students
and their friends. Do parents encourage their children to take MFAs in
Creative Writing? Can students afford to do so without having to incur
debts the size of a mortgage before they graduate? These programs lead
to more poetry books available to be read by the general public and more
instructors to teach the general public’s children. It seems like a
healthy contribution to me, except for the debt.
I think in Canada there are certain schools, but it isn’t cut in
stone. For example, I would say that Cobourg poet, Stuart Ross, a
long-time former resident of Toronto, is a mentor for contemporary
surrealism and the small press in Canada. He offers poetry boot camps,
manuscript editing and has recently published a book called
Our Days in Vaudeville
through Mansfield Press, that is a collaboration with 29 other poets,
which is a terrific example of reaching out to others in the literary
community. He was a writer-in-residence at Queens University in
Kingston, Ontario a few years ago and mentored several emerging writers,
including Michael E. Casteels, who is a small press owner through his
chapbook press, Puddles of Sky, in Kingston.
In Ottawa, rob mclennan is an active promoter and publisher of poetry
with his small press above/ground press which publishes chapbooks and
broadsides he distributes en masse throughout the world. He also curates
a series of on line magazines and is co-publisher of Chaudiere Books,
with his wife, fellow poet, Christine McNair. Through these presses and
publications, he has introduced numerous writers from around the world
to each other and has put Ottawa on the map as a happening literary
centre. His 12 or 20 questions series with writers and small press
publishers is a great initiative that allows readers to learn about the
writers and their works in greater detail.
He has also offered workshops and if he’s the mentor for any
particular school, I’d call it the contemporary poetry playbox. He
introduces budding poets to the works of contemporary poets they might
never have heard of and encourages them to play and experiment. I myself
took numerous workshops from him and have learned of/been inspired by
the works of Nathanël, Erín Moure, Dennis Cooley, Fred Wah, Robert
Kroetsch, Cole Swensen, Paige Ackerson-Kiely, Kate Greenstreet and more,
thanks to rob’s efforts at fostering community.
What are the “actual” or fictional/utopian/dystopic communities in your poetry/in poetries you enjoy or are familiar with?
I’m fascinated with the idea of fictional/utopian and dystopic
communities. My poetry lives in the world of my whacky imagination. And I
can’t help but be influenced by the creative works of others, both
living and dead.
When I first began to draft this piece, I was working on (and
probably still am) a poetry manuscript which centres around a woman’s
belief that she is Saint Ursula. I am fascinated with saints and
historical figures, but not so much with what actually happened to them.
The fun for me is in extrapolation. The work concerns a homeless woman
who has visions. Through it, I’d like to explore the issues of
homelessness here in Ottawa and also chronic pain, depression,
schizophrenia etc. When I was in hospital in 2009, I had ICU psychosis,
causing terrifying delusions that I believed to be real. It made me
worry for those who have to experience such delusions in their daily
lives. I’ve written of hell based on Dante’s Inferno via these delusions
and the pain I endured during my health crisis.
I also write fiction and my characters are generally bad-asses, who
don’t really fit in very well with convention. I have written a few
stories set in the period leading up to and after an apocalypse where
characters are fighting to survive in draconian circumstances. I find it
satisfying to write out my fears and as a reader, I find dystopic texts
compelling. I guess it’s a bit like being a rubber-necker at an
accident: we don’t want to look at scenes of grisly death, but we can’t
tear our eyes away. Sometimes it helps to understand that we are all
suffering; there’s a camaraderie in that. These tales also serve as
morality plays for what might happen if we continue to a) use up all the
resources in our environment; b) continue to place a low priority on
those less fortunate…
Wouldn’t it be fun to write within the perspective of a Utopian
community! My ideal world entails free love, the end to heteronormative
monogamy as the dominant culture, the disappearance of gender binaries,
solutions to homelessness, poverty, disease and war. In addition I would
like a fully funded arts and culture program, and an endless supply of
strong coffee and profiteroles please.
Is your poetry/are your poems a community? In what way(s)?
I typically write long poems and poem series. I think each one of
them is a community. Sometimes they are populated with invented or
historical characters; other times they are populated with soundscapes
(“Sessions from the Dream House Area,” excerpts of which can be found on
17 Seconds Magazine
here), metal textures (
Me, Medusa,
a chapbook published on line by the UK Press, the Red Ceilings Press).
Sometimes they interact quite directly with the work of other poets
(Ghazals Against the Gradual Demise: chapbook 1 – “
Sex First and Then A Sandwich” is in response to Jim Harrison’s ghazals; “
The Sad Phoenician’s Other Woman” is in response to Robert Kroetsch’s “The Sad Phoenician.”
Could you give us a few considerations on/tentative predictions
regarding the future involvement of poetry in the life of communities,
or the other way round: the impact of future possible or virtual
communities on poetry and their depiction in poetry?
I think we’ll need more curators to guide us in the increasing miasma
that is the Internet. As independent bookstores, which used to be the
primary hub for readings and author signings, close, we will need other
ways to promote and foster a community of readers. In Ottawa in the last
few years, we’ve seen the closure of several bookstores, including
Collected Works and Mother Tongue Books. Both of which held numerous
readings in their stores and sold poetry by local poets.
Sites like
GoodReads.com and Canada’s the
49thShelf.com,
OpenBookOntario,
Lemonhound.com,
help to maintain a literary community and inspire readers to purchase
books, either on line or in print. There are a number of excellent
literary journals on line:
DitchPoetry.com,
Numero Cinq (a warm place on a cruel web),
the Volta,
The Conversant,
Penn Sound and
Jacket2.
As postal service is reduced, it is probably true that printed journals
will cease to exist, which saddens me immeasurably, but these online
hubs, for want of a better term, offer a lot of possibilities that
printed journals cannot offer.
I tried to get into Second Life, the virtual reality / role playing
game which also seems to have poetry readings somehow. It wasn’t for me,
but perhaps others will find this sort of thing a help in fostering
community.
I really like the idea of poetry events being broadcast live. The
Griffin Poetry Prize for example, always streams the shortlisted
readers. I wish the sound quality and video quality was better, but I
think that’s coming.
Another cool thing is the book trailer where authors read excerpts
from their books which are translated into short films. I think this is
exciting, but it has to include an element of feedback, of direct access
to the writer, either through social media or e-mail. I know many
authors balk at the idea of such direct contact with readers, but for
those who enjoy it, we are in a time of great opportunity for
interaction between fans and creators. Take a look at the
Moving Poems site, which has a huge list of poetry book trailers.
Brick Books, a Canadian publisher, has a slew of
audio recordings of its poets and is at the forefront of ensuring all kinds of readers have access to poetry for free through these podcasts.
Two festivals, the Ottawa International Writers Festival and
VERSeFest work with local schools to offer programs where authors are
invited to schools to read and talk with children. The Ottawa Public
Library and local writers organizations also offer similar activities,
such as writing contests for young people. These programs seem to be
increasing rather than diminishing.
The League of Canadian Poets in collaboration with an advertising
company is publishing poems on public buses in a program called “
Poetry In Transit.”
I have read great poems by poets such as Dionne Brand, P.K. Page and
Robert Kroetsch whilst standing on a crowded #95 en route home after a
long day in a Byward Market café, penning my own poems and hanging out
with fellow poets. Life is rough!
Community radio stations such as Carleton University’s CKCU and the
University of Ottawa’s CHUO have programs which feature the arts,
particularly poetry on shows such as
Friday Special Blend with Susan Johnson,
Literary Landscapes with Pearl Pirie, Dave Currie, Kathryn Hunt and Neil Wilson, and
Click Here with Mitchell Caplan. The hosts interview poets and publishers on their programs. The CBC through shows such as
Writers and Company with Eleanor Wachtel and
The Next Chapter
with Shelagh Rogers, also broadcast interviews and highlights literary
work, including, on rare occasions, poetry. You can listen to these
programs live or as podcasts later on.
I believe all of the above initiatives and activities bring poetry to
the community and community to poets. You don’t have to live in the
city where a reading is taking place in order to enjoy the work of the
poet in the poet’s own voice, for example. And with the help of good
curators, this information can be passed on to those new to poetry.
Not to discount the reading as a great opportunity as well. Ottawa is
a city full of readings of poetry and fiction. While there’s a tendency
for such readings to attract the same old die-hard enthusiasts, there
are often at least one or two Ottawa newbies who found out about the
reading through a friend or some online resource, such as Bywords.ca.
‘Poetry’? What kind of poetry, if any? How does poetry look in
that (any?) picture (of the future), if in any way present? And
speaking of virtual, what do you think is or could be the communal
relevance of digital/electronic/new media poetry? Is Marjorie Perloff
right when she states in Unoriginal Genius that writing the new century
poem (concerning itself not with inventio but with the processing and
absorption of the foreign itself, and therefore typically proceeding by
[inter/hypertextual] sampling and appropriation] is no easier than it
ever was, just different?
I think poetry looks very much the same in many ways with books and
chapbooks and online journals but as I said, print journals may go the
way of the dodo. I think digital poetry combined with animation will be
of interest to some people as it is now and perhaps more so. I can even
imagine poetry book trailers beginning a film in a theatre, much like
animations do today.
I’m hoping that poetry pioneers such as Christian Bök who combines
science with poetry will continue to thrive. I hope that there will be
more hybrids and fewer genre labels on types of creativity. I hope that
the audience for poetry or for these hybrids will increase.
Do we want to see the end of copyright? How does plunderverse as described by
Gregory Betts
and other forms of appropriation fit in to what is legal or acceptable
when it comes to publishing? Will publishers be willing to risk lawsuits
and fines if they publish text recycled from others?
I’d like to be able to play with whatever is available. The Internet has made it easier to cut and paste text. I think of
Jonathan Ball
who licensed his poetry under Creative Commons so that others would be
able to take the text and do what they like with it, including creating
new forms of art. Take a look at Gary Barwin’s
reversals of parts of Ball’s book, “Clockfire.”
I think that being able to work with existing texts or music or art
opens up the possibility for creativity, so I’m all for it, provided
people give credit where credit is due. The Internet has made it
possible for people from all over the world to contact one another. This
has also paved the way for collaborative poetry projects.
The Finnish visual poet Satu Kaikkonen has few blogs where she
invites contributors from all over the world to participate. See Time
for a
Vispo.
Or, even beyond virtual community, in Mark Surman and Darren
Wershler-Henry’s terms, what is the place of poetry in the “common
space” and in the age of the “power of the collective,” and what kind of
poetry could that be?
I hope that poets continue to question the dogma and propaganda that
is prevalent in society, thanks to increasing Big Brother presence,
censorship and double speak of government and large corporations. The
poet is the canary in the coal mine, n’est-ce-pas? I am hoping that
grassroots collectives such as the Occupy Movement, Idle No More and
other activist groups continue to grow and gain support and that artists
and writers who question the dogma are able to thrive, but I worry that
Conservative intolerance for unconventional lifestyles, non mainstream
thinking and the power and corruption of right-wing forces will keep
free thinkers underground. The fact that we have to be concerned with
governments monitoring our social media and Internet interactions is
very scary to me. It shows there is a need now more than ever to make
art and to find ingenious ways to disseminate it, as Diderot did during
the creation of L’Encylopédie when he published entries that challenged
the status quo under mundane items such as “Souliers” [shoes].
And, if, as a well-known playwright twitted a few months ago and
then a Washington Post article elaborated on, “poetry is dead”—which is
also the name of an excellent Vancouver based poetry magazine—is there
any (chance for a) post-history post-poetry out there, or in here, in
your verse?
T.W. Adorno wrote that “After Auschwitz to write a poem is
barbaric;”yet we have an impulse to bear witness. I think this is more
important than ever today. The Serbian poet Vasko Popa was one of the
writers who utilized symbolism and allegory in his work to personalize
and portray the horrors of war at a time when literal renderings were
censored. Poetry is an ideal and subtle means of articulating the
dangers of acceptance of the status quo and a way to question the
language of propaganda. I think for this reason alone and there are many
other reasons to add, it will survive because it is needed by the
reading public to help us translate and convey emotion, tragedy, comedy
and life in all its myriad and complicated facets. To create art is to
survive and to rebel against convention.
I think poetry will continue to exist, change and adapt as it has
always done, and to serve an audience. I have no intention of stopping
writing poetry or whatever hybrid I choose to create, even if I had a
choice in the matter. As Mark Twain once said, “Reports of my death are
greatly exaggerated.”
—————————–
Amanda Earl is an Ottawa poet, publisher and
pornographer. She defends your right to express your creativity in
whatever way you please. She is the managing editor of Bywords.ca and
the (fallen) angel of AngelHousePress. Her poetry has been published
both on line and in print in America, Australia, Canada, England, France
and Ireland. Her visual poetry has been exhibited in Russia and
Windsor, Ontario. Her most recent poetry chapbook,
Sex First & Then A Sandwich is available from above/ground press. For more information, please visit
AmandaEarl.com or talk to her on Twitter @KikiFolle.